If you’re an accountant in the UK, you’ve probably already heard whispers about mandatory payrolling of benefits in kind. It’s one of the biggest changes to hit payroll and benefits reporting in years, and it’s going to touch almost every business that provides a company car, medical cover, or any other taxable perk to its staff.
The good news is that HMRC has given everyone a bit more breathing room. The bad news is that the change is still coming, and it’s coming in stages that need careful planning. Let’s break down what’s actually happening and what it means for the clients you support.
What is mandatory payrolling of benefits in kind?
Right now, most employers report benefits in kind after the tax year ends, using P11D and P11D(b) forms. Employees often don’t feel the tax hit until months later, sometimes through a confusing tax code adjustment the following year.
Payrolling changes that timing. Instead of tallying everything up at year end, the employer adds the taxable value of the benefit to pay and collects Income Tax on it there and then, through the same Full Payment Submission (FPS) already sent to HMRC each pay period.
Employers have had the option to do this voluntarily since 2016. What’s changing is that it stops being optional. Class 1A National Insurance will also need reporting and paying through payroll, rather than being settled in one go the following July.
The revised timeline
This is the bit clients want clarity on, because the start date has already moved twice. It was originally due in April 2026. HMRC pushed that back to April 2027 after software providers and professional bodies raised concerns about how workable the original plan actually was.
Then, in June 2026, HMRC went further and split the rollout into two phases rather than mandating nearly everything at once.
Phase 1: from 6 April 2027
Mandatory payrolling begins with:
- Company cars
- Car fuel
- Vans
- Van fuel
- Employer provided medical benefits, including private medical insurance
That list looks short, but HMRC reckons it covers around 92% of all benefits provided by UK employers. So the impact is far broader than the five bullet points suggest.
Phase 2: from 6 April 2028
Most of the remaining benefits follow a year later. This staggered approach gives employers, agents and software providers longer to get real time reporting working properly before it applies across the board.
What's still out of scope
Employment related loans and living accommodation stay outside mandatory payrolling for now. Employers can keep using P11D and P11D(b) for these, or register to payroll them voluntarily if they’d rather. Voluntary registration for loans and accommodation opened in November 2026.
The official confirmation of dates and scope sits on the GOV.UK policy page for changes to reporting of benefits in kind from April 2027, which is worth bookmarking, since HMRC continues to update it as the details firm up.
Why HMRC is bothering with this
It isn’t just an administrative tidy up. HMRC wants to close the gap between an employee receiving a benefit and paying tax on it, meaning fewer surprise bills and fewer confusing tax code shifts. It also fits into HMRC’s wider push towards real time payroll data, something that’s been building for a decade now.
How this actually lands on your clients
For plenty of clients, especially smaller ones who’ve never payrolled benefits before, this changes how payroll gets run each month, and means it is no longer just a form that disappears.
Benefit values are needed earlier and more often
Instead of pulling figures together once a year for the P11D, employers now need benefit values as they arise, so they can be added to the right pay period. That means tighter coordination with fleet providers, insurers, and whoever else supplies the underlying data.
Estimates will sometimes be unavoidable
HMRC accepts that exact figures won’t always be available in time. Employers will need to use a reasonable estimate where necessary, with a year end process in place to sort out any under or overpayments afterwards.
Payroll software has to keep up
Not every system currently handles in-year benefit reporting the way HMRC wants. Clients on older or less flexible software may need an upgrade, and that’s worth raising well before 2027, not in the weeks beforehand.
Employees will need an explanation
Staff will start seeing deductions in their regular payslip rather than one adjustment months later. Without a clear heads up, that tends to generate confused emails, so it’s worth planning how clients will explain the change to their teams.
A softer line on penalties, at least initially
HMRC has confirmed a light touch approach for the first year. Through 2027/28, penalties for inaccurate reporting will generally only apply where non-compliance is deliberate, with the usual rules kicking back in from 2028/29. Handy breathing room, but not an excuse to leave preparation until later.
What to be advising clients now
See who’s actually affected
A quick audit of everything currently on the P11D tells you who lands in phase 1, who’s in phase 2, and who barely notices the change at all.
Check the payroll software
Talk to providers now about whether they’re ready for real time benefit reporting. Leaving this until 2027 doesn’t give much room to fix gaps.
Weigh up voluntary payrolling
Some clients might prefer to payroll benefits outside phase 1 voluntarily, rather than juggling two separate reporting processes at once. The window to register for 2027/28 closed on 5 April 2026, but future registration periods are expected, so it’s worth keeping this on the radar.
Plan the employee messaging
A short, plain English explanation of why payslips are changing saves a lot of back and forth once payrolling actually starts.
Keep an eye on further HMRC updates
HMRC has said it’s still working through details like globally mobile employees and directors with no regular employment income. More guidance and draft legislation are expected through 2026 and into 2027, so this isn’t a topic to read once and shelve.
Final thoughts
Mandatory payrolling of benefits in kind sounds like a technical reporting tweak, but it changes how clients run payroll month to month, not just what they file at year end. The phased approach buys some time, though it also means two systems running side by side for a while, with its own complications.
If you’d like a hand getting clients ready before April 2027, whether that’s reviewing benefits, checking payroll readiness, or talking through the detail, Stellaripe’s outsourcing team works alongside UK accountants on exactly this kind of transition. Contact us today!